Please allow cookies to start chat.
Timing is everything with review requests. The most valuable feedback comes when customers are ready to share a positive experience. At peak times like BFCM, that means holding back until the dust settles. Here’s why delaying requests works, and how to get the timing right.
Please Note:
Account details may vary. The feature is now part of the subscription

Holiday sales bring a surge in orders, and with them, a huge opportunity to collect reviews. But if you send requests too early after BFCM, you risk reaching customers mid-frustration. 

They may still be waiting on deliveries, chasing support, or drowning in emails. And that can lead to poor review scores that damage your reputation.

That’s why it pays to get strategic. 

REVIEWS.io Flow, our automation tool for smarter review collection, lets you control exactly when and how requests are sent. 

That means you can avoid many of the issues that lead to negative reviews, and instead capture more positive and helpful feedback.

Summary

  • Sending review requests too soon after BFCM risks negative feedback linked to delivery delays, support backlogs, and inbox fatigue.
  • The smartest approach is to think in phases, holding requests until customers are ready and following up once they have real experience to share.
  • Different types of products move through these phases at different speeds, so timing should reflect the customer journey, not the calendar.
  • REVIEWS.io Flow automates review collection by delaying requests, adding conditions, and sequencing follow-ups to match customer readiness.
  • Flow is more than a delay tool. It builds in personalization, UGC collection, reminders, and value-building campaigns that maximize every interaction.

Why delay review requests after BFCM?

BFCM changes the way customers experience your brand. It’s hectic, demanding, and often unpredictable. 

A smart BFCM review strategy means knowing when to time requests, because sending them too soon risks feedback shaped by seasonal challenges rather than the product itself.

Shipping delays

Courier networks are under intense pressure during BFCM, with delays unavoidable even for the most efficient merchants. 

If you request a review before an order arrives, customer frustration with delivery overshadows their product experience.

Support backlogs

Customer service teams are overwhelmed with enquiries during peak trading. From stock issues to damaged parcels, merchants typically see a 20% increase in support tickets over BFCM.

Asking for reviews while tickets are still open risks capturing unresolved frustration.

Price regret

BFCM is all about discounts, and even satisfied customers may stumble on a better deal after buying. 

By asking for their feedback too soon, you risk it reflecting regret over price, not the quality or value of what you deliver.

Inbox fatigue

In the days after BFCM, inboxes are bursting with promotional emails, shipping notifications, and confirmations. 

Adding your review request into that chaos almost guarantees it will be ignored or resented.

Rushed feedback

When you ask too soon, customers have barely had a chance to use the product. 

The result is vague, low-value reviews like “Looks good” or “Arrived on time” that don’t build trust or drive conversions.

The smartest BFCM review strategy is patience. Waiting ensures reviews reflect products, not problems.

What’s the optimal timing for BFCM review requests?

BFCM shifts the normal purchase journey, so the best time to ask for reviews isn’t about a calendar date - it’s about recognizing when customers are genuinely ready.

Think in phases, not fixed days.

Phase 1: delivery pending

  • Customers are still waiting on deliveries or dealing with early issues. This is the blackout period where review requests should be paused.

Phase 2: post-delivery use

  • Orders are delivered, most issues are resolved, and customers start using products. This is the right moment for first review requests.

Phase 3: established experience

  • Customers have had time to form confident opinions. This is when reminders and UGC requests add value. 

How these phases apply by vertical

Each vertical moves through the phases at a different pace, and during BFCM those timelines are stretched further by seasonal pressures:

Fashion & everyday retail

  • Moves into post-delivery use fairly quickly.

  • During BFCM, customers are usually ready for invites around 10 - 14 days after completion, once deliveries land and return decisions are made.

Tech & luxury

  • Takes longer to reach post-delivery use.

  • In BFCM, this can be 3 - 4 weeks after completion, when setup is done and early support issues are resolved.

Consumables (food, beauty)

  • Enters post-delivery use almost immediately.

  • But with dispatch backlogs at BFCM, requests should go out 5 - 7 days after delivery to make sure products are in hand and tried.

Supplements & results-based products

  • Customers only reach established experience after consistent use.

  • With BFCM delays, feedback is most meaningful 3 - 4 weeks after delivery, when results are noticeable.

How does Flow adapt review requests to the BFCM journey?

Flow lets you build these differences into your strategy:

  • Trigger requests from order completion (or delivery confirmation if required), ensuring they don’t go out during the blackout period.

  • Apply delays that reflect how long each vertical takes to move from phase 1 to phase 2, so requests land when customers are genuinely ready.

  • Sequence reminders and UGC requests in phase 3 automatically, so follow-ups feel natural and timely.

Flow adapts review timing to each product journey - essential during BFCM’s unpredictable peak.

How to optimize your review request flows

Flow isn’t only about sending review requests at the right time. It’s about maximizing every interaction. 

By layering additional triggers and rules, you turn review collection into a system that improves both the quantity and quality of feedback.

UGC collection: trigger photo and video requests after positive reviews to capture authentic visuals. User-generated content adds credibility and is proven to boost conversions.

Personalization: send product-based invitations that reference exactly what the customer bought, or build country-specific flows so timing and messaging reflect local expectations.

Reminders: automate email or SMS follow-ups to lift completion rates. SMS is especially powerful here, converting up to 3x higher than email.

Value-building campaigns: use Influence to reward reviewers with loyalty points or referral perks. This turns a review request into an opportunity to encourage repeat business.

Continuous optimization: test different timings, channels, and request styles. Monitor performance and feed back into your Flow to create a system that continually improves.

Flow goes beyond timing. It makes reviews richer, smarter, and more valuable to your business.

Best practices for protecting your reputation during BFCM

Delaying requests avoids many problems, but you also need to safeguard your reputation once reviews start coming in.

  • Link reviews to support: connect REVIEWS.io with Gorgias to add review data to support tickets. This gives agents the full picture and helps them deliver better service.
  • Request revisions after resolution: invite customers to update negative reviews once their issue has been resolved, so feedback reflects the outcome.
  • Monitor sentiment: use REVIEWS.io’s AI Assistant to analyze reviews and spot patterns before they escalate.

Protecting your reputation means acting on reviews, not just collecting them.

Make reviews work harder this BFCM with REVIEWS.io Flow

During BFCM, patience is essential. Delaying requests avoids frustration and ensures feedback reflects the product, not the chaos of peak season. 

With REVIEWS.io Flow, you can adapt to each phase of the BFCM journey, build in safeguards, and use features like personalization, reminders, and UGC requests to maximize the value of every interaction.

Already using REVIEWS.io? Set up a Flow sequence to make sure your BFCM invites are perfectly timed.

Not yet a REVIEWS.io customer? Book a demo with our team today and see how Flow can help you protect your reputation and generate more impactful reviews.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to pause review requests during BFCM?

It’s a good idea to hold requests immediately after BFCM while orders are still in transit and inboxes overloaded. With REVIEWS.io Flow you can build in a blackout period to avoid poorly timed invites.

When is the best time to send review requests after BFCM?

Once orders have been delivered and customers have started using their products. The exact timing depends on the product type and how long it takes for customers to form real opinions.

What should I do if I get negative reviews after BFCM?

Respond quickly and professionally so customers feel heard. Route low-star reviews to support, and once issues are resolved, invite customers to update their feedback.

Can I send review requests differently for different products?

Yes. REVIEWS.io Flow allows you to set product-based rules so consumables, fashion, tech, and supplements all have delays that fit the customer journey.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★
9,000+ brands rely on REVIEWS.io to scale further & faster

Book Demo