Ecommerce
Incentivized Reviews: Whatâs Allowed, Whatâs Not, and How to Use Them Effectively
August 6, 2025
â˘
8 min read
Instead of browsing pages of links, shoppers now see AI-generated recommendations from platforms like Google, ChatGPT, and Perplexity. To secure visibility in those recommendations, you need Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) - and verified review data is your most powerful asset. Reviews donât just drive trust; they decide whether your brand appears at all.
But reviews are just the start. To maximize BFCM results, this blog highlights complementary quick-win tactics - from sweepstakes to loyalty to returns management - supported by tools in the clearer.io ecosystem. Together, theyâll help you grow your audience, protect your reputation, and keep more revenue during the busiest shopping period of the year.
If you want to dominate BFCM, reach is everything. The bigger and more engaged your audience, the better your chances of making it a blockbuster event. Sweepstakes can be a quick win.Â
Offer a prize that directly appeals to your target market, and run the competition across your social media and website. This tactic rapidly grows your email list and following with people who are genuinely interested in your brand. And every new subscriber is a potential future reviewer that strengthens your credibility.
FlySafair, for example, ran a sweepstake offering free flights for a year and captured data from 154,795 entries just by adding a link on their landing page. They drove over 18,000 Facebook shares and 12,000 tweets, massively expanding reach.
âAnd with the ViralSweep + REVIEWS.io integration, you can combine traffic and trust in one campaign. Run a sweepstake, capture leads, and display review snippets or incentivize review submissions directly within the entry flow - all from a single platform.
QUICK TIP:
Use sweepstakes to grow your audience and collect fresh reviews before the big event.
Get started with ViralSweep today.
If you have a loyalty program in place, use it to your advantage by creating special offers for your top-tier members. Offering early access to your BFCM deals and exclusive perks not only keeps your best customers engaged but gives them a compelling reason to choose you over cut-price offers from competitors. Itâs not just about retention; itâs about driving more revenue from your most loyal and valuable customers.
For example, Sephoraâs âBeauty Insiderâ rewards top-tier members with early access to Black Friday deals. This creates urgency, drives early sales, and keeps their most loyal customers coming back.
â
With Influenceâs Memberships feature, you can now segment customers into VIP groups and deliver tailored perks. Want to create a BFCM-only membership with exclusive early access? Or reward VIPs with monthly perks that expire to drive urgency? Memberships - and the latest automation updates like Recurring Rewards and Discount Expiry - make this possible without the admin overhead.
Encourage referrals too: 84% of consumers trust recommendations from friends, and shoppers are 4x more likely to buy when referred. With Influence, you can combine referral incentives with early-access perks to maximize engagement.
QUICK TIP:
Use Memberships to give top customers early access - and automate perks to keep them coming back.
BFCM brings an influx of new customers, along with the opportunity to collect a high volume of product reviews. But it also brings a surge in orders across eCommerce as a whole, leading to potential delays that are often beyond your control. In 2023, 54% of negative reviews during BFCM were due to late shipments. To avoid this damage, pause your review requests to give a grace period for orders to reach recipients before asking for feedback.Â
Protect your ratings by pausing review requests until deliveries are complete. Then resume with empathetic messaging like âThanks for your patience!â or âSorry for any holdups!â. By managing the timing of your review requests, you can protect your ratings and enhance your brandâs reputation during BFCM.
QUICK TIP:
Hold off on review requests until deliveries are completed, giving customers time to enjoy their purchases.
âTry out REVIEWS.io for free now!
Discounts are expected during BFCM, but they donât have to eat into margins. Instead of focusing solely on markdowns, use AI-powered recommendations to boost basket size and add value for your customers.
This strategy not only drives higher AOV but works even better when paired with reviews. With the Boost + REVIEWS.io integration, shoppers can filter and sort products based on star ratings, or see review scores directly in search results. That extra trust makes recommendations more persuasive and leads to faster conversions.
You can also capture last-minute revenue with Boostâs checkout product recommendation widgets. These personalized suggestions appear right on the checkout page, giving customers one final opportunity to add relevant products without disrupting their payment flow.
QUICK TIP:
Use AI to bundle frequently bought-together items, add review signals to search, and surface personalized upsells at checkout.
Sign up for Boost Commerce today!
Failed deliveries cost money and hurt reputation. A single error can cost up to $18 in re-shipping and handling fees, and 85% of shoppers say a poor delivery experience stops them ordering again.
As order volumes spike during BFCM, errors increase. Implementing an address validator ensures every order is checked and corrected at checkout - preventing costly mistakes and protecting customer satisfaction. And by avoiding delivery complaints, you safeguard your review scores.
QUICK TIP:
Implement an address validation tool to ensure every order reaches the right destination.
Add Address Validator to your tech stack today!
During BFCM, customers often buy multiple sizes or variations of products to ensure they get the right fit or style, leading to an inevitable increase in returns. But with the right approach, you can turn potential losses into gains. Nudge customers toward exchanges over returns with incentives like free shipping or small discounts on the new item. This simple tactic can make exchanges the more attractive option and help you retain the revenue youâve already earned.
Itâs also crucial to have a clear and simple returns policy in place. About 67% of customers check the return policy before making a purchase. If they see that your process is straightforward, theyâre more likely to convert. In fact, displaying a clear returns policy can reduce cart abandonment by 20-30%. By making the returns process easy and offering incentives for exchanges, you can turn potential losses into wins, keeping your customers satisfied and your revenue steady during BFCM.
Returns are inevitable during BFCM - but you can still keep revenue in-house. Incentivize exchanges over refunds with free shipping or small discounts on replacement items.
A clear, simple returns policy also reduces cart abandonment. 67% of customers check return policies before purchase, and displaying one clearly can cut abandonment rates by 20-30%.
With Rich Returns, you can streamline exchanges even further thanks to multi-carrier support. Connect providers like UPS, EasyPost, or Shippo and let the system automatically choose the most cost-effective return option - saving money while keeping customers happy.
QUICK TIP:
Offer incentives for exchanges - and use smart carrier selection to reduce costs.
Try out Rich Returns today with a free demo.
Maximizing your BFCM success doesnât have to be overwhelming. Start with the foundation of trusted reviews from REVIEWS.io - they fuel visibility across AI search, TikTok Shop, and the Shop app, while giving shoppers the confidence to buy.
From there, layer on complementary tools from the clearer.io ecosystem for quick wins:
With REVIEWS.io at the core, and the right supporting tactics in place, you have everything you need to grow reach, protect your reputation, and drive more revenue this BFCM.
Ready to transform your BFCM strategy? Book a demo with REVIEWS.io today!
Run a sweepstakes with a relevant prize to quickly build your email list and social following.
Pause review requests until orders are delivered, then follow up with tailored messages.
AI can suggest personalized bundles and frequently bought-together products, boosting average order value.
Use an address validation tool to catch errors before orders ship.
